PolkaWorld voted NAY.

Two-thirds opposed, one-third in favor.

Opposing points:

Deploying smart contracts on Polkadot AssetHub is essential before any future developments can proceed, such as those described in the proposal:

•	Goal of integrating at least 15 games (including local and external Web2 games)

•	Hosting 150+ tournaments: prize pools of 60–300 DOT, over 6–12 months

•	Collaborating with esports organizations for flagship events to enhance visibility

However, AssetHub’s launch timeline has not yet been determined, and Q3 is a broad range. It is currently difficult to assess the effectiveness of spending these funds. We recommend applying again once AssetHub is live.

Supporting points:

This mechanism aligns with many gaming users’ engagement habits. Based on the website and related materials, the team’s activity frequency and community engagement appear to be good.

Regarding the proposal’s mention of launching 15 games, I understand that this is not strictly tied to AssetHub’s launch, and some work can be initiated in advance. However, if deployment on AssetHub is required, some technical adaptations or adjustments might still be needed. The team is advised to further confirm and clarify this point.

Please see the full feedback here.

Dear @N3MUSNeal,

The preimage for your proposal, 0x890...d59, does not exist on-chain. Therefore, our first vote is nay on this proposal. Please reach out to us for any questions or updates.

Kind regards,
Permanence DAO
Decentralized Voices Cohort IV Delegate

📅 Book Office Hours
💬 Public Telegram
🌐️ Web
🐦 Twitter
🗳️ Delegate